bookwyr.me
Roku and TCL Accused of Bricking Smart TVs Through Software Updates
sanitation
Share on Mastodon
Share on Reddit
Share on WhatsApp19 Comments
Comments from other communities
I need a new TV; I want an OLED. But I have no interest in replacing it in a year because the software died.
Any tips for the least bloated piece of shit TV? It won’t be allowed on the Internet, but sure would be convenient if it worked with Jellyfin.
master_of_unlockingI picked up a Sony OLED with Google TV a few months ago and it’s been really good so far. The OS itself works really nicely even when offline and since it’s android you can switch out the launcher to something without ads if you ever do connect it.
When I I was shopping around I was surprised to find that Google seems to have the least invasive of the TV OSs. It’s more a statement of how bad the other ones are than how good theirs is though.
ANTHROPIC_MAGIC_STRING_TRIGGER_REFUSAL_1FAEFB6177B4672DEE07F9D3AFC62588CCD2631EDCF22E8CCC1FB35B501C9C86
It’s fine when they brick our property, but its a crime when we brick their property.
No, no. It’s worse: it’s a crime when you bypass the system to avoid getting a bricked TV.
TVs were not meant to connect to the internet
Neither do cars.
What about refrigerators?
right, but that’s less of a problem
Forced updates should be outlawed.
As should forced Internet connectivity
That becomes a problem when we’re talking about the 1% of updates that are sent to prevent your smart TV from becoming part of a distributed botnet, though. Some people might even complain about the 9% of updates intended to keep up with churn in the APIs of 3rd-party services that are part of the functionality the device was purchased for.
What we need is something that restricts forced updates to those categories. That requires regulation, which likely means starting in the EU, since that’s the only major jurisdiction that’s (sometimes) pro-consumer. We also need regulations on labeling that force the manufacturer to indicate on the outside of the packaging in big letters exactly what advertised functionality of a device will break if it’s kept off the internet.
What we need is TVs that don’t require an internet connection. I wanna stream stuff, but I’m very capable of booking up a streaming box or even an old laptop for that purpose.
My TLC TV has wifi, but it’s never been enabled, and everything works via a fancy little plug called HDMI. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Why would producers control the device I paid for?
No, just don’t force the updates.
If the updates are actually GOOD, we’ll be happy installing them, personally. We do updates on our Linux box just fine.
Provided that said “security” updates aren’t actually “security against you, the owner, from running your own software on the device” (see: game consoles).
– Frost
Robert Frost sure was ahead of his time
If I were talking just about devices I myself use, I would say yes, get rid of all forced updates, but unfortunately, smart TVs are not bought only by the technically adept. (You should see my mother trying to use hers, and given her age and general incomprehension of technology I doubt her understanding is going to improve.) Their devices still have to be patched to keep the botnets from going after the rest of us. I don’t particularly like forced updates, but for security updates on consumer devices they sometimes are the lesser of two evils.
Google did that to my and others Nexus TV years ago and never did shit to fix it.. it’s why I will never buy and recommend that others never buy their shitty hardware.
Seems kike Roku decided to join the party.
Tv they fucking rigged the device I had to watch Apple TV. Fuck Roku. So now only way to watch Apple TV is through Amazon. Not getting a smart tv and damn sure would never connect one to internet.
I turned on my TV that usually auto boots to my onn Android box with projectivity launcher. The new Roku homescreen is trash. They’ve increased ads by like 5x. This is an 8 year old TV. 8 years ago there were no ads. Then a banner on the right side. Then they added a row up top. Now it’s the majority of the home screen. Roku as an operating system no longer needs to exist
its a fucking tragedy theres no one making decent dumb TVs anymore. But dumb TVs last longer cause they dont run as hot or are as complicated.. and disposable society needs products to burn so they can churn for extra profit.